Dear J-
I’ve spent the weekend ripping digital copies of the DVD movies we own — this weekend it was time to concentrate on the Disney Animated Canon — based on convenience and fear. First off I want to be able to broadcast these to other devices around the house so that means finding a solution for that, sharing; secondly, the unskippable advertisements have gotten obnoxious — hello, we already own most of the 50-movie canon (I counted; and lastly, figgy has proven unusually adept at putting discs in and taking them out, which means with optical media that it’s only a matter of time before we lose or scratch something. And as far as Blu-Ray* goes I’m convinced that’s a format designed to drive you back into the greasy arms of the theaters: once the movie gets going it’s spectacular but getting there is an even bigger struggle than with DVDs which in turn were more annoying than VHS and LaserDisc.
That sharing solution, at least for me (OS X setup), goes like this: use RipIt to extract the disc, play the disc using preferred settings via DVD Player to figure out what te right title to extract is, then use HandBrake in specific title mode to pull the right data and convert it to iTunes format. We have an AppleTV hooked up to the TV so that automatically syncs with the computer and pulls media from it. It sounds complicated** (you could do it all the extraction and re-encoding in HandBrake) but I’m awfully pleased with RipIt — it is a no-fuss tool that does one thing and does it transparently well, no babysitting required. HandBrake in comparison is a bit of a beast, very flexible but nearly incomprehensible without some experimentation.
Thus far it all works shockingly well. If you have to beam content around the house there are various ways to do so but I like the server + client model (and this is not unique to OSX, though I’ve been completely intimidated out of trying it on Linux via one of the XBMC forks; just reading some of the setup questions gives me a headache) and it has the added benefit of nigh-instant access and one-box convenience, sort of like an iPod that’s permanently wired to your TV. The best part for me is stripping out all the extra junk: I used to pay extra for special bonus disc editions but have since come to realize how little I actually watch them. Right now it’s about fair use of what we own and not wasting our time with what the studios have forced down your throat.
Mike
* Plus we don’t have a Blu-Ray player any more. And you don’t need to be a technician to figure out how to run DVD like you do with Blu-Ray.
** I also wanted to check how much faster the new computer is (Core i7 Quad versus Core Duo) — short answer is that HandBrake runs better than four times faster and will digest a movie in roughly half an hour or so. Now the question is about storage: each rip is uncompressed from the original disc and clocks in at 5-8GB apiece. Disk space is cheap, and I need to get some more.