Dear J-
The love-hate relationship I have with my bike centers around its reliability; while I have no significant complaints about the frame (it has borne my carcass around for over two years without significant complant), the drivetrain and componentry scream that it was built down to a price, and that’s where the compromise was forged. I remember going in to the bike shop to explain what kind of chain I needed (“Yes, it’s a nine-speed Sunrace. Stop laughing.”) and that exact moment of realization that I’d either need to start taking better care of it, or face the all-too-frequent breakdowns I am now. Today I had a flat on the way in — halfway along, and too late to turn back to get the car.
What I really need is something with solid tires and a sealed drivetrain; I could live without the suspension on the back, which has ended up causing nothing but compromise after compromise (difficult to fit a fender or a rack, and it seems to cause the chain to derail every time I go over a bump). I could get better tires, but the dream of going to hub gearing would mean that I’d need to upgrade the crank as well (it is depressingly cheap, like the rest of the components). I am unstintingly cheap about these things, though the difference would be having a bike I didn’t have to worry about versus the occasional pain of having downtime to fix the beast.
I suppose like everything else it comes down to how much you value your time: is it worth doing, and is it something you enjoy doing? I think even if I had a workshop and tools, I’d still resent having to fix up another tool I use to get to and from work; there’s too much else to do and enjoy to have to worry about things that should just work. It was just about seven years ago, in fact, while I was teaching myself TeX that I started to realize these things: instead of shelling out a few bucks on a shareware text editor with basic formatting capabilities, I convinced myself that TeX was the way to go — it was, after all, the professional typesetter’s choice. Stepping back twenty years in user interface (there’s a reason every computer comes with a mouse, after all) — or finding ways to make your life harder isn’t the right direction.
Mike